Searching over 5,500,000 cases.


searching
Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.

State v. Gover

Court of Appeals of Ohio, Tenth District

August 1, 2013

State of Ohio, Plaintiff-Appellee,
v.
Michael A. Gover, Defendant-Appellant.

APPEAL from the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas (C.P.C. No. 05CR-04-2375)

Ron O'Brien, Prosecuting Attorney, and Steven L. Taylor, for appellee.

Michael A. Gover, pro se.

DECISION

CONNOR, J.

{¶ 1} Defendant-appellant, Michael A. Gover ("defendant"), appeals the August 15, 2012 judgment entry and order of the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas, which denied defendant's motion for new trial and dismissed his fourth petition for post-conviction relief. Finding that the trial court did not abuse its discretion, defendant's assignments of error are overruled and the judgment of the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas is affirmed.

I. FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

{¶ 2} The facts and procedural history of this case were sufficiently set forth in our prior decision ruling on defendant's direct appeal from his convictions. There, we explained the events which gave rise to this case as follows:

The charges in this case arose out of the stabbing death of Jason Schmalenberger ("Schmalenberger") that occurred on April 3, 2005, near the intersection of State Route 317 and Parsons Avenue in Franklin County, Ohio. The autopsy revealed approximately six stab wounds to Schmalenberger, two to the front of his chest, one to his left, front thigh, one to his right foot, one to his left buttock, and one to his left, back thigh. The chain of events leading up this incident were adduced at trial, and are summarized in the following paragraphs.
On April 2, 2005, Amber Weakley, Jerry Weakley's ("Weakley") sister, had a party at Weakley's residence. Among the guests at the party were appellant, Charles Dickerson ("Dickerson"), Sirquan Allen ("Allen"), Melvin Taylor ("Taylor"), and appellant's girlfriend Amanda Fisher ("Fisher"). After the party, the named individuals spent the night at Weakley's. The next day, Weakley decided to give all of them a ride home in his girlfriend's car, a blue Topaz. Weakley, accompanied by appellant, Fisher, Dickerson, Allen, and Taylor, stopped at a convenient store, and then proceeded to Fisher's house near Parsons Avenue. Fisher got out of the car and Weakley and the remaining passengers drove away. However, they returned to Fisher's house twice because of items she had left in the car. When leaving Fisher's house for the final time, Weakley was driving, Allen was in the front passenger's seat, appellant, Taylor, and Dickerson were all in the back seat, appellant being seated behind Weakley.
Weakley was traveling on a residential street with cars parked on both sides, when he came in contact with a van traveling in the opposite direction that had "Co-Vad" written on its side. According to the testimony of the car's occupants, the van swerved in their direction, causing Weakley to swerve to avoid a collision. Weakley described that everyone in the car got a little agitated, and some occupants started yelling. One of the occupants stated that the van's driver "should get his ass kicked." (Tr. at 216.) Appellant told Weakley to "turn around, " and said things like, "let's go get him." Id. According to Dickerson, though the conversation in the car was "what the hell happened?" and "go follow them, " appellant was the loudest of the group and "pretty insistent" about turning around to follow the van. (Tr. at 392.) In response to the van's alleged swerving, appellant said, "Fuck that. Don't nobody play me. Turn around." (Tr. at 391.) Appellant also stated, "I'm going to get that mother fucker." (Tr. at 488.) Though Weakley hesitated about turning around, according to Dickerson, appellant kept insisting, and after about thirty seconds, Weakley complied.
There were two, possibly three cars in front of Weakley as he caught up to the van. At an intersection, the cars turned off leaving the Topaz directly behind the van. Weakley sped up and proceeded to pass the van on Parsons Avenue. At the next stop sign, Weakley stopped, and everyone, except for Weakley, exited the car. Appellant went to the van's driver's side, and appeared to start fighting with the driver, Schmalenberger, while another man held the passenger side door shut. The men thought that it was a fistfight, but at some point, it was discovered that Schmalenberger had been stabbed a number of times with a knife. According to Franklin County Deputy Coroner, Dr. Collie Trent, Schmalenberger died as a result of two stab wounds that penetrated his heart and the area around it. During the altercation, Schmalenberger's cousin, Rick Rice ("Rice"), who was the passenger in the van called 911.
Immediately after the fight, the four individuals ran back to the Topaz, and they fled. During this time, according to Weakley, appellant stated, "I'm a killer, I'm a killer." (Tr. at 223.) As a police car pulled up behind the Topaz and activated its siren, Weakley pulled off into a parking lot, whereupon appellant attempted to give the knife to Dickerson, who refused to take it. Thereafter, appellant opened the car door and dropped the knife into the parking lot. The police then approached the Topaz with guns drawn and all the occupants were taken into custody. A search of the area resulted in finding a bloody knife in the parking lot. Excluding appellant, all of the car's occupants testified at trial that appellant was the only one involved in the physical altercation with Schmalenberger, and that appellant had a bloody knife in his possession after the confrontation.
According to Rice, he and Schmalenberger were on their way to play golf on the afternoon of April 3, 2005, when they were passed by a blue Topaz driving very fast. At the stop sign, the occupants of the Topaz got out and began running towards the van. Rice tried to get out, but one man held the door shut. Appellant pulled Schmalenberger's door open and Rice saw Schmalenberger getting punched and trying to push appellant away. Rice heard appellant say, "Give me my knife" three times. (Tr. at 794.) At this point, Rice did not know that Schmalenberger was getting stabbed. Rice was calling 911 as Schmalenberger was asking for help. Rice tried to jab appellant with an "ink-pen-looking device" that was in the van's console, but to no avail. As he stayed on the line with 911, the four men ran back to the Topaz, and Rice told Schmalenberger to follow them. Schmalenberger did so for a few hundred yards, but then Schmalenberger looked at Rice and said, "I am not doing so good." (Tr. at 795.) Schmalenberger fell over as the van coasted into the guardrail, and at this time, Rice realized that Schmalenberger had been stabbed. Rice held Schmalenberger until the ambulance arrived.
On April 12, 2005, appellant was indicted by a Franklin County Grand Jury on one count of aggravated murder, with prior calculation and design, one count of murder, during the course of a felony, and one count of tampering with evidence, to wit: a knife. The aggravated murder and murder charges carried repeat violent offender ("RVO") specifications alleging that appellant had a prior conviction for voluntary manslaughter. The case proceeded to jury trial. Appellee requested, and received, a nolle prosequi on the murder charge. The jury found appellant guilty as charged of aggravated murder and tampering with evidence. Pursuant to appellant's jury waiver regarding the RVO specification, the matter was tried to the court, and the trial judge found appellant guilty of the RVO specification. The trial court sentenced appellant to life ...

Buy This Entire Record For $7.95

Download the entire decision to receive the complete text, official citation,
docket number, dissents and concurrences, and footnotes for this case.

Learn more about what you receive with purchase of this case.